Some schools with crumbling concrete may have to be demolished, experts warn

Logo The IndependentThe Independent
2023-09-06 13:26:24  • 5 mins

Some of the English schools found to have the crumbling concrete may have to be demolished if repairs become too expensive, experts have told The Independent.

Rishi Sunaks government under fire over years of underinvestment in school repair work has been told it could be more cost effective to write off some of the older affected schools and build new ones.

Asbestos problems in some of the 147 schools identified as having reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (Raac) the problem material compared to an Aerobar could complicate remedial work, said building specialists.

Adrian Tagg, associate professor of building surveying at Reading University, said trying to make some older schools safe could become prohibitively expensive if asbestos was found.

The expert said: If you have building from the 1970s thats 50 years old the cost-benefit analysis is, Do we demolish and put a new structure in place with a 50-year life or do we try to extend by 20 years?

Experts have warned that trying to remove or bolster Raac in ceilings or floors can increase the danger of exposure to asbestos. If Asbestos is disturbed it can release fibres which can cause mesothelioma and lung cancer.

Continue read on independent.co.uk

Watch live as Gillian Keegan, the education secretary, takes questions in parliament on schools affected by crumbling concrete and the impact on children's...
The number of schools found to contain dangerous crumbling concrete has jumped to 174, with Raac found on 27 sites since the end of August. A total of 23...
Logo The IndependentThe Independent
2023-09-19 09:26:37  • 1 min
The number of schools in England where reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (Raac) has been found has risen from 147 to 174, the Department for Education...
The number of schools in England affected by crumbling concrete has increased to 174, new figures published by the government show. The number stood at 147...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-19 08:39:46  • 1 min
By Finn Purdy BBC News NI Surveys will be carried out at 120 schools across Northern Ireland to check for collapse-prone concrete, the Education Authority...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-18 14:50:50  • 1 min
The rebuilding of a secondary school found to have crumbling concrete should be "accelerated", a Labour MP has said. Mary Foy complained of a lack of...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-19 17:11:55  • 1 min
By Robbie Meredith BBC News NI education correspondent It is unclear if Northern Ireland will receive extra money from the UK government to fix public...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-23 05:51:50  • 1 min
By Susie Rack BBC News, West Midlands A school for autistic pupils has partially closed after widespread unsafe concrete was found. Baskerville School in...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-19 14:54:05  • 1 min
A Moray school is to remain shut on Tuesday amid faulty concrete fears. Forres Academy closed its doors to more than 800 pupils last Thursday after experts...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-18 15:09:46  • 1 min
More than half of the NHS buildings in Scotland which are suspected to contain a potentially dangerous form of concrete have not been fully inspected....
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-23 11:46:46  • 1 min
By Matt Precey & Ben Schofield BBC News, Essex A "money saving" programme to remediate Essex schools affected by reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-19 04:53:45  • 1 min
By Vanessa Clarke Education reporter The government is expected to issue an update to its official list of schools in England with reinforced autoclaved...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-19 02:22:51  • 1 min
By Simon Dedman and Nic Rigby BBC Politics East The cost of sorting out crumbling concrete at one school was likely to come to 1.25m, a head teacher has told...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-16 18:30:46  • 1 min
By Pritti Mistry BBC News Several classrooms and buildings have been closed at Grantham College after potentially dangerous concrete was found at the site....
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-19 13:13:38  • 1 min
The collapse-risk concrete at the centre of a crisis in school buildings has been found in parliament. The presence of reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete...
Logo The GuardianThe Guardian
2023-09-11 18:51:06  • 1 min
A hospital in Wales has admitted that patients have been at risk for 'many years' after crumbling concrete was detected throughout its premises. Bosses at...
Logo Daily MailDaily Mail
2023-09-11 16:26:43  • 1 min
A primary school near Northampton has been forced to close for two days following the discovery of concrete that is prone to collapse. The reinforced...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-11 13:46:49  • 1 min
By Peter Walker BBC News, Essex The concrete crisis affecting schools in Essex can be traced back to a "formidable" architect in the 1970s, research by the...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-15 05:04:48  • 1 min
Essex has long been stereotyped for its bubbly TV personalities, but these days it is better known for its bubbly school roofs. The preponderance of...
Logo The GuardianThe Guardian
2023-09-13 09:00:05  • 2 mins
By Nathan Standley BBC News "Several hundred" surveys are now being carried out every week to find schools containing collapse-prone concrete in England,...
Logo BBCBBC
2023-09-11 17:55:02  • 1 min